Game Changer Academies at the National Science Foundation
Participant Readiness to Make a Difference
In our multi-year collaboration with the National Science Foundation’s CMMI division, we asked participants to rate themselves on 16 common panel review discussion challenges. Graduates of the program demonstrated significantly higher confidence in their ability to navigate complex dynamics to engage in fair and reasonable discussion of complex arguments. These results are from the 2024 cohort.
















CMMI’s Game Changer Academies
(C-GCA)
The National Science Foundation’s CMMI division enlisted the GCA curriculum as the foundation for C-GCA (CMMI’s Game Changer Academies).
The NSF’s rigorous funding process depends on rapid, yet thorough, deliberation and decision-making by expert panels. C-GCA maximized the quality of these crucial deliberations to provide high-value feedback to program officers.
As of December 2024, 682 members of the CMMI community completed the C-GCA program. Graduates of the C-GCA program are better equipped to contribute to the advancement of the United States as a global leader in science and engineering.
Rob Stone, CMMI Division Director, 2018-2022, describes the motivation for C-GCA as an investment in research innovation.
C-GCA graduates apply these skills in many other professional settings.
90% in other interactions with colleagues
I have been better able to slow down my thinking when presented with an opinion that I do not agree with.
I have applied a couple of [the 11] discussion behaviors to my lab discussions. In particular, summarizing helped us a lot be on the same page and move forward.
73% in faculty meetings
In one faculty meeting we were discussing a curriculum revision. Some of my colleagues took others’ comments personally and ended up an unhappy and ended the discussion. After the meeting, I forwarded everyone a video I [saw during this course] about 5 ways of approaching disagreement and conflict. I guess some of them got it and their behaviors in the following meetings were a little bit better.
65% in other review contexts
I am chairing an important committee for [my professional association]. The discussions are sometimes emotional because members have different opinions on how to evaluate the accomplishments from practitioners vs academia’s. [Because of GCA], I know how to manage the discussion, how to encourage participation, and how to guide the committee to make a fair decision. This course helped me understand conflicts are common and that there are ways to resolve the conflicts and move on with the agenda.
